Opens in a new tab

One in Six MEWP Hires Goes Wrong. Here’s What It’s Costing Contractors in the North

New research with 300 site, project and procurement managers puts a number on the real cost of unreliable access equipment hire, and the figures for northern cities are worth a closer look.

Anyone who books MEWPs regularly knows that if a scissor lift turns up two hours late or a boom cuts out halfway through a job, you are up against it. And accepting these issues will cost you.

But when you add up what those failures actually cost, the problem is significant. Therefore, Horizon Platforms commissioned Censuswide to find out how often hire goes wrong and what it costs contractors. The short answer: about one in six hires has a problem, and each one costs far more than the hire itself.

Who Was Asked

Censuswide surveyed 300 people across the UK in planning and management roles: project managers, contract managers, site managers, health and safety directors, procurement managers and operations managers. Every one of them works in construction, mechanical and electrical, or facilities management, and every one of them hires MEWPs.

The National Picture

On average, respondents told us that:

  • 15.7% of hires were delivered late
  • 18.6% broke down on site
  • 16.4% turned up as the wrong machine
  • A single incident cost £6,343 once idle labour, re-hire, overtime, penalties and extra admin were added up
  • 80% had seen a hire failure extend a project that was already delayed by planning or regulatory approval

That last figure is the one that stings. A job that is already behind gets pushed back further by something that should have been the easy bit.

How the North Compares

MetricLeedsLiverpoolManchesterSheffield, York & HullUK
Avg cost of most recent hire issue£2,827£6,046£8,528£5,701£6,343
Mean projects delayed2.32.22.73.32.3
% with 3 to 5 projects delayed38%33%49%64%34%
% extended an already-delayed project62%75%76%80%80%
% hit with contractual penalties54%83%76%55%72%
Late delivery (mean % of hires)11.5%12.6%20.8%7.3%15.7%
Breakdown on site (mean % of hires)8.2%17.8%23.3%11.5%18.6%

Source: Censuswide survey of 300 UK professionals who hire MEWPs, commissioned by Horizon Platforms, May 2026. Regional sample sizes vary.

Leeds: Lower Cost per Incident, but the Disruption Is Still There

Leeds came out with the lowest average cost per incident anywhere in the survey, at £2,827. That is around £3,500 below the national figure, and on the face of it that is good news.

Look a bit further down the table, though, and the picture is less rosy. Late delivery still affected 11.5% of hires. 62% of Leeds respondents said a hire failure had pushed back a project that was already running late, and more than half (54%) had been hit with contractual penalties as a result. Nearly half (46%) said they were likely to change supplier in the next 12 months.

So, each incident may cost less in Leeds, but they keep happening, and the knock-on effect on programmes is just as real. For contractors working across the city, having a local supplier you can count on makes a big difference. Horizon provides scissor lift hire and cherry picker hire in Leeds from its West Yorkshire base, with 98% of hires completed without an issue.

Elsewhere in the North

Manchester had the highest cost per incident in the North at £8,528, about 34% above the national average. Late delivery hit 20.8% of hires and on-site breakdowns 23.3%, both well above the UK figures. Perhaps unsurprisingly, Manchester contractors were also the most willing to pay more for a reliable supplier, at 15.6% on average.

Liverpool stood out for contractual penalties. 83% said a hire failure had triggered one, the highest of any city in the survey, and 75% said they were likely to switch supplier.

Sheffield, York and Hull were grouped together in the research. This region had the highest share of respondents (64%) reporting three to five delayed projects in the past year, and 80% said hire failures had extended jobs that were already behind. When that many projects are slipping, it stops being bad luck and starts being a pattern.

The Cheap Hire Rate Trap

Across the UK, respondents said they would be willing to pay 13.2% more, on average, for a supplier that gave them reliable, consistent service. Yet plenty of MEWPs are still hired on rates alone.

It is easy to see why. The hire rate is right there on the purchase order. The cost of a failed hire is not. These unwanted and avoidable additional costs turn up when teams are standing around waiting, a subcontractor is rebooked, overtime is paid, or a penalty clause kicks in. None of that changes the hire invoice, but it significantly changes margin. Plus, issues impact a business’s reputation.

One national fit-out contractor hiring around 220 machines a month found this out the hard way. It was dealing with 28 hire issues a month, roughly one in eight, and estimated it was losing between £7,000 and £14,000 a week as a result. After moving its MEWP hire needs to Horizon Platforms, issues dropped to fewer than one a month. The hire rates were higher. The total cost was a lot lower.

Five Questions to Ask Your Hire Supplier

If any of this sounds familiar, these are worth asking before your next order. But if you can’t get answers to these questions, alarms bells should ring loudly:

  1. What percentage of your hires pass without a problem?
  2. How is each machine checked before it leaves the yard?
  3. If a machine breaks down on my site, what happens and how quickly?
  4. Will I have one named person to deal with, or a general phone line?
  5. Are you IPAF Rental+ accredited?

Work Out Your Own Number

The averages above are a starting point, but your own figure is what matters. Take how many machines you hire a month, assume one in six has a problem, and multiply by what an incident costs you.

For example, a contractor hiring 40 machines a month would expect six or seven problems. Even at the Leeds average of £2,827 an incident, that is close to £19,000 a month that never shows up on the hire invoice.

Once you have that figure, the question is simple. Is the saving on the hire rate worth it if one bad week wipes it out?

You can read more about this data at horizonplatforms.co.uk/blog/the-true-cost-of-poor-hire-and-how-to-calculate-yours

About Horizon Platforms

Horizon Platforms is an employee-owned MEWP hire and training company based in Normanton, West Yorkshire, supplying scissor lifts, cherry pickers and other access platforms to contractors across the UK.